Lemon meringue pie

Taste Our Homemade Pies

For more than 50 years, McClures Bakery has been making award-winning pies using our one-of-a-kind, tried-and-true recipes. Our bakery is famously known for our award-winning shoofly pie. With a wide range of choices, you are sure to find a dessert that fits your palate.

Our Pies are sold in 8-inch, 9-inch, and 10-inch sizes. They are overflowing with flavor and perfect for parties and family gatherings.

We offer the following pie flavors:

  • Shoofly
  • Chocolate Shoofly
  • Pecan
  • Coconut Custard
  • Egg Custard
  • Cherry Custard
  • Lemon Sponge
  • Peanut Butter
New Project

Fruit Pies

All our fruit pies are freshly baked everyday and filled with the finest fruits available. You can count on us for the following fruit pie flavors:

  • Apple
  • French Apple
  • Cherry
  • Blueberry
  • Raisin
  • Peach
  • Apple Dumplings (Single or Three-Pack)
New Project (1)

Cream Pies

Our premium cream pies will definitely tempt your taste buds. This dessert is oozing with goodness and will leave you wanting more. 

  • Lemon Meringue
  • Chocolate Cream
  • Banana Cream
  • Coconut Cream
  • Boston Cream
  • Cherry Boston Cream
  • Strawberry Cream
  • Blueberry Cream
  • Peach Cream

We have partnered with Goldbelly to ship our award winning Shoofly Pie and Whoopie Pies around the nation.

New Project (2)

Lancaster County Pennsylvania Dutch Shoofly Pie

For more than 30 years, we have been serving Lancaster County’s best-tasting pie! This 10-inch, 32-ounce, restaurant-sized pie is made from scratch. Made with our very own pie crust, delicious molasses-based filling, and a couple of secrets thrown in, this freshly baked confection is truly Lancaster County’s Best! Our Wet Bottom Shoofly Pie is now available for shipping! Place your order today and have it delivered to your doorstep!

New Project (3)

Whoopie Pies

Whoopie pies are actually more like a sandwich, made of two cake-like cookies with a cream center. We have the following flavors to choose from:

  • Chocolate
  • Red Velvet
  • Pumpkin

Seasonal Pies

Whether you are having a Thanksgiving or Christmas gathering, our seasonal pies are perfect to sweeten your holidays. We have pumpkin and mincemeat pies that are made fresh and hot from the oven.

Send Us a Message

Come by our bakery and treat yourself to some fresh goodies today! You may also contact us today for pie orders. We'd love to hear from you!