From Our Oven to Your Table
We Offer Freshly Baked Cakes, Pies, and Breads
Welcome To McClure's Bakery
Your Source for Delightful Baked Goods
Located in the heart of Amish Country, McClures Bakery has been bringing delicious Amish baked goods to our customers for more than 50 years. The bakers at our family-owned and operated bakery specialize in making shoofly pies, cakes, bread, and other traditional recipes using the finest ingredients. One taste of our wonderful products & we are sure you will agree that you've found something special.
Remember that life is short, eat dessert first
Whether you are looking for whoopie pies, shoofly pies, or other traditional Amish goods, we have you covered! For more than 50 years, our staff has been offering quality, handcrafted products that are made from scratch and baked fresh.
Our storefront and wholesale bakery in Gap, Pennsylvania is part of a bigger company, Lancaster Old Fashioned, LLC. Led by our owners, Tom and Jamie Keenan, we strive to continue the Lancaster County traditions.
Connect With Us
Visit our retail store to try any of our cakes, pies, or bread. If you are interested in becoming a wholesale customer, reach out to our friendly staff today. We look forward to helping you satisfy your baked goods cravings.